PFC News Alert:

Demonstration against Ken Zucker

(the man who proposes reparative therapy for gender variant kids)



From: "Tracy Dean"

To: "UKPFC-News"

Sent: Monday, September 22, 2008 12:12 PM

Subject: UK: Zucker Demonstration London - October 1st 2008 8.30am

Demonstration against Ken Zucker (the man who proposes reparative
therapy for gender variant kids)

October 1st, 8.30am, The Royal Society of Medicine, 1 Wimpole Street,
London W1G 0AE

The demo is organised in cooperation with the Metropolitan Police and
will take place outside the Royal Society of Medicine

(Just behind Debenhams/House of Fraser, Nearest tubes are Bond Street
and Oxford Circus)

Please come if you can.

Natacha Kennedy (Official Organiser)

#### NB. This is not a Press for Change organised event, but Press for
Change encourages its members to take part if they can.####

This is an important demonstration and it is vital that you attend if
you are able. As it is on a Wednesday at 8.30am there are quite a few
people who would like to come but are unable to make it because of work

It is important to come for two reasons;

1.     to show opposition to Ken Zucker's 'treatments' being used on
children and

2.     to oppose the nature of the Royal Society of Medicine's highly
political conference on trans identified adolescents.

Ken Zucker is a psychologist (not a psychiatrist) at the Clarke
Institute in Toronto. He promotes his so-called "reparative therapy"
which is little more than torture for gender variant(GV) children and
trans identified adolescents. It is suggested by research that around
75% of born male bodied children who manifest GV behaviour (sissy boys)
do not become trans adults, but it is worth noting that this research
has never considered born female bodied GV children (tomboys). Yet he
promotes his 'therapy' for all GV children and trans identified adolescents.

Ken Zucker also proposes to use "reparative therapy" on these young
people, regardless of their parents' wish or the young person's legal
right to access this treatment. In the UK, a young person (YP) has a
variety of ways in which they can request treatment and give full
consent to it; with their parent's approval, and if required, regardless
of their parents' wishes i.e. when the YP is 16 (under the Family law
Act) or even younger when they are 'Gillick Competent' which requires
far greater competence than is every required of an adult accessing
treatment, i.e. they understand the nature of the treatment, what it
does, what it doesn't do, all the side effects and other consequences,
and the health risks they are taking.

For the 25% who will become trans identified (and the unknown proportion
of the rest who are actually suppressing it or hiding it as a result of
bullying, parental pressure etc.), the results of treatments like
Zucker's can be catastrophic. Victims of this therapy are left
traumatised for a very long time afterwards. They experience frequent
feelings of depression and suicidal tendencies. This is not surprising
since this treatment involves constantly telling these YPs that they are
wrong, everything they do, are or feel is bad, and clothes, toys and
other possessions relating to their preferred gender are taken away and
they are punished for engaging in activities which reflect their own
true identities. They are also rewarded for any behaviour which reflects
the gender their parents wish them to be. This is just crude
psychological and emotional bullying and exertion of power over those
unable to defend themselves.

This treatment is not just wrong, but has no basis in psychological
theory and is considered by many psychologists and psychiatrists to be
the equivalent of voodoo or unproven 'alternative' medicine. It is also
wrong because it is a response to the wishes of the many homo & trans
phobic parents who demand their child is 'normal', rather than to the
needs of the YP. Although parental wishes may be taken into account,
when a YP is under 16, the YP is the patient and any doctor is bound by
ethics to consider the YP's needs as paramount. We do not believe this
is happening in Zucker's clinic.

It would also appear that this therapy is related to some of the ideas
of the extreme Christian right-wing political lobby in the United States
which has sponsored this type of therapy to "treat" homosexuality. This
therapy is designed to pander to parents who would like to have a
'normal' child. Children are, however, not a fashion accessory. We
believe that this therapy violates the UN Convention on the Rights of
the Child, and the European Convention on Human Rights.

Secondly, the Royal Society of Medicine describes itself as an
"apolitical organisation", yet this conference seems to have been set up
by its organisers in the most political way possible. By inviting Zucker
to contribute regarding his 'therapies' and not allowing any
representation from anyone to oppose him this is clearly a political
move. Even Mermaids, the organisation for trans children & young people,
and their parents has not been allowed to contribute. Given Zucker's
highly controversial place on the DSM-5 committee on GID this alone is
an extremely political act. The only likely opposition is from Professor
Peggy Cohen-Kettenis, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam but she is
on the same DSM-5 committee as Zucker - can they really give a fair view
point between them. And there is no legal overview given, Professor of
Law, at Manchester Metropolitan University; Dr Stephen Whittle from
Press for Change who has written on the legal issues (see *** below) has
not been invited.

Furthermore, the welcome address is being given by Dr John Scadding,
Dean of the Royal Society of Medicine and Professor Philip Steer,
President Elect, Section of Obstetrics and Gynaecology, RSM  is
reviewing questions of prognosis and long term follow up.

However it appears to go further than this. The conference seems to have
been set up to push a UK-based treatment protocol for GV children and
trans identified adolescents. This protocol will not involve the use of
hormone blockers to delay the onset of puberty. Puberty can not only be
extremely distressing for some GV YP's particularly those that grow up
to be trans adults. Furthermore,  as legal research has shown the
refusal to consider this treatment  means that trans adolescents develop
secondary sexual characteristics, such as beard or breast growth that
ultimately lead to major health interventions, in the future, which
could have been avoided. In this sense it seems that it is also
particularly politically motivated and as such as large presence outside
is vital to make our feelings known and to distribute leaflets to
delegates to make sure they understand the other side of the story.

It is rather ironic, but Professor Melissa Hines, Faculty of Social and
Political Sciences, Cambridge will be contributing information on
Endocrine influences. She is the wife of Professor Richard Green, who
has himself been so perturbed by this conference that he has arranged an
alternative conference; Conference on Medical Care for Gender Variant
Teenagers,  on September 28th at Imperial College in London, to
challenge it. (for further details go to: )

Demonstration against Ken Zucker (the man who proposes reparative
therapy for gender variant kids)

October 1st, 8.30am, The Royal Society of Medicine, 1 Wimpole Street,
London W1G 0AE

Please Join Us

Natacha Kennedy

*** Whittle, S., Downs, C., 2000, Seeking a Gendered Adolescence: ;Legal
and Ethical Problems of Puberty Suppression among Adolescents with
Gender Dysphoria In E Heinze, ed. Children's Rights: Of Innocence and
Autonomy, Aldershot: Dartmouth Press, pp 195-208, pages: 13

This message comes to you from Press for Change, the UK's trans
    rights campaign.
You cannot post to UKPFC-NEWS.  To submit a news item for
    distribution, please send email to
To unsubscribe, email
The list administrators can be contacted at

DISCLAIMER: This email may include material written by third parties,
    which is distributed for information only and may not reflect the
    views or policies of Press For Change.

FORWARDING: Whilst we welcome posts being forwarded to third parties,
    we do ask that you forward this message in its entirety, complete
    with its attribution and this footer.