Message Number: 806
From: James W Mickens <jmickens Æ eecs.umich.edu>
Date: Sun, 9 Sep 2007 21:45:45 -0400 (EDT)
Subject: Re: mind the gap
> Generating wealth (producing a good or service) does not hurt any one. 
> If the new product or service is produced more efficiently or is more 
> desirable than the other products on the market, it may change the 
> conditions that other people had been previously exploiting to create 
> wealth.  But, it does not negatively impact another person's current 
> wealth.

This isn't true. For example, wealth-generating factories may create 
pollutants. These pollutants can negatively impact my environmental 
wealth, e.g., if I own a fishery that is downstream of your dumping pipe. 
My ability to grow fish, i.e., my ability to generate wealth, is hurt by 
your ability to make wealth. As another example, generating wealth for 
shareholders may be inversely related to generating wealth for the actual 
workers in the company. If the company produces a more efficient service 
because my wages have been slashed, but this newfound efficiency increases 
the wealth of the stockholders, then I've lost wealth as a result of 
others gaining it.

~j